登陆注册
37836700000090

第90章 VOLUME II(8)

Now for each of these in its turn. His first item is that the Rio Grande was the western boundary of Louisiana, as we purchased it of France in 1803; and seeming to expect this to be disputed, he argues over the amount of nearly a page to prove it true, at the end of which he lets us know that by the treaty of 1803 we sold to Spain the whole country from the Rio Grande eastward to the Sabine. Now, admitting for the present that the Rio Grande was the boundary of Louisiana, what under heaven had that to do with the present boundary between us and Mexico? How, Mr.

Chairman, the line that once divided your land from mine can still be the boundary between us after I have sold my land to you is to me beyond all comprehension. And how any man, with an honest purpose only of proving the truth, could ever have thought of introducing such a fact to prove such an issue is equally incomprehensible. His next piece of evidence is that "the Republic of Texas always claimed this river [Rio Grande] as her western boundary." That is not true, in fact. Texas has claimed it, but she has not always claimed it. There is at least one distinguished exception. Her State constitution the republic's most solemn and well-considered act, that which may, without impropriety, be called her last will and testament, revoking all others-makes no such claim. But suppose she had always claimed it. Has not Mexico always claimed the contrary? So that there is but claim against claim, leaving nothing proved until we get back of the claims and find which has the better foundation.

Though not in the order in which the President presents his evidence, I now consider that class of his statements which are in substance nothing more than that Texas has, by various acts of her Convention and Congress, claimed the Rio Grande as her boundary, on paper. I mean here what he says about the fixing of the Rio Grande as her boundary in her old constitution (not her State constitution), about forming Congressional districts, counties, etc. Now all of this is but naked claim; and what I have already said about claims is strictly applicable to this.

If I should claim your land by word of mouth, that certainly would not make it mine; and if I were to claim it by a deed which I had made myself, and with which you had had nothing to do, the claim would be quite the same in substance--or rather, in utter nothingness. I next consider the President's statement that Santa Anna in his treaty with Texas recognized the Rio Grande as the western boundary of Texas. Besides the position so often taken, that Santa Anna while a prisoner of war, a captive, could not bind Mexico by a treaty, which I deem conclusive--besides this, I wish to say something in relation to this treaty, so called by the President, with Santa Anna. If any man would like to be amused by a sight of that little thing which the President calls by that big name, he can have it by turning to Niles's Register, vol. 1, p. 336. And if any one should suppose that Niles's Register is a curious repository of so mighty a document as a solemn treaty between nations, I can only say that I learned to a tolerable degree of certainty, by inquiry at the State Department, that the President himself never saw it anywhere else. By the way, I believe I should not err if I were to declare that during the first ten years of the existence of that document it was never by anybody called a treaty--that it was never so called till the President, in his extremity, attempted by so calling it to wring something from it in justification of himself in connection with the Mexican War. It has none of the distinguishing features of a treaty. It does not call itself a treaty. Santa Anna does not therein assume to bind Mexico; he assumes only to act as the President--Commander-in-Chief of the Mexican army and navy; stipulates that the then present hostilities should cease, and that he would not himself take up arms, nor influence the Mexican people to take up arms, against Texas during the existence of the war of independence. He did not recognize the independence of Texas; he did not assume to put an end to the war, but clearly indicated his expectation of its continuance; he did not say one word about boundary, and, most probably, never thought of it. It is stipulated therein that the Mexican forces should evacuate the territory of Texas, passing to the other side of the Rio Grande; and in another article it is stipulated that, to prevent collisions between the armies, the Texas army should not approach nearer than within five leagues-- of what is not said, but clearly, from the object stated, it is of the Rio Grande. Now, if this is a treaty recognizing the Rio Grande as the boundary of Texas, it contains the singular feature of stipulating that Texas shall not go within five leagues of her own boundary.

Next comes the evidence of Texas before annexation, and the United States afterwards, exercising jurisdiction beyond the Nueces and between the two rivers. This actual exercise of jurisdiction is the very class or quality of evidence we want.

It is excellent so far as it goes; but does it go far enough? He tells us it went beyond the Nueces, but he does not tell us it went to the Rio Grande. He tells us jurisdiction was exercised between the two rivers, but he does not tell us it was exercised over all the territory between them. Some ******-minded people think it is possible to cross one river and go beyond it without going all the way to the next, that jurisdiction may be exercised between two rivers without covering all the country between them.

同类推荐
热门推荐
  • 天行

    天行

    号称“北辰骑神”的天才玩家以自创的“牧马冲锋流”战术击败了国服第一弓手北冥雪,被誉为天纵战榜第一骑士的他,却受到小人排挤,最终离开了效力已久的银狐俱乐部。是沉沦,还是再次崛起?恰逢其时,月恒集团第四款游戏“天行”正式上线,虚拟世界再起风云!
  • 蚁族白领追爱记

    蚁族白领追爱记

    蚁族碰到白领,当废柴碰到精英,会擦出什么样的火花?废柴!小心眼的废柴,可爱的废柴,仇富的废柴,天天蹭网偷菜的废柴,每个月领了薪水却仍然被迫贫穷的废柴……哦,废柴,你天天刷光总裁的菜是为哪般?
  • 魔帝的天才狂妃:逆天三小姐

    魔帝的天才狂妃:逆天三小姐

    她一辈子活着只为了报仇,直到下一世,她发誓,只为自己而活!国安局史上最强特工醒来,竟是一个废的不能再废的哑女!坐拥至宝,开启异瞳,探索斗气流转,吸收星辰之力!他,冷清孤傲,漫不经心。他是杀伐果断的冷面战神,遇上了傲娇腹黑无与伦比的她,“卑鄙阴险的蠢女人”:“死不要脸的倒贴门”,究竟是棋逢对手,还是互相沦陷?群雄追鹿,异军突起,玄元至尊即将开启时空之门!
  • TFBOY的black女孩

    TFBOY的black女孩

    如果没有黑夜,是否,就只存在白昼;如果没有黑暗,是否,就只存在光明;如果从未遇见你,是否,我就不会如此心痛。(tfboys王俊凯以一种尴尬的方式,邂逅一位女孩,并经历相识,相知,相恋,全过程。)
  • 帅宝宝:酷爹地萌妈咪

    帅宝宝:酷爹地萌妈咪

    她无辜的学生,天生的设计灵感;他帝国总裁。一次次意外让他们暧昧不清,突然来的意外让她对他动心............
  • 上古幻魔录

    上古幻魔录

    人生苦短,自愿不甘平凡。为此付出一生,为代价,欲想修得好果。可天却不明,世人不懂。只注重于结果,偏偏而遗忘了其中的过程。力量强与弱,真的就这么大区别吗?..........内心强大,才是真正强大。
  • 快穿之绝对宠爱

    快穿之绝对宠爱

    洛安不懂什么是历劫,她只知道寒渊君死了,再也回不来了。历劫失败的寒渊君丢了三万年的道行,回天上第一件事,就是要找出那个害自己历劫失败的罪魁祸首,还真叫他找着了,竟然是他不知道什么时候带回天上的一颗明珠。最要命的是,他的明珠暗淡无光,隐隐透着死气。为了把这颗罪恶的明珠救回来,寒渊君决定再入一次三千世界,他一定要让着颗小东西付出代价!!!
  • 七转天轮剑

    七转天轮剑

    曾经的天才,现在的废物;唯一一位引起悟剑崖剑潮,却只能佩一把无属性的破剑
  • 绿的歌:冰心晚作辑萃

    绿的歌:冰心晚作辑萃

    这部《绿的歌》有着举足轻重的价值,它代表着冰心的第二个创作高峰。它里面的《自传》系列、《关于男人》系列,以及论教育的系列杂文,特别是《我请求》、《无士则如何》等,以及像《病榻呓语》、《霞》等散文名篇,都是她晚年的代表作。这里面不但有一位世纪老人的过人的智慧、超人的毅力、非凡的活力,还有一个特殊时代的独特气息。它将中国带入了一个全新的局面,掀开了历史的全新的一页。
  • 逆几率系统

    逆几率系统

    余秋:「给我最难练的秘籍!」「咚!逆几率系统启动,修练成功率由0.001变为99.999%」这是一个余秋带着逆几率系统,挑战最高难度的故事。在他面前,困难不是问题,简单才是问题。群聊号码:4814206032018三江推荐作品,品质可靠!